Ted Manzer: Hornbeam is another native tree with winter landscape appeal

0 Comments | Leave a Comment

Acouple of weeks ago I wrote about river birch and its beauty in winter. It’s just one of several useful native species. Many are underused in my opinion.

One of my personal favorites for naturalizing is a birch relative with many different common names. Carpinus caroliniana is called American hornbeam, ironwood, blue beech, water beech and musclewood. Musclewood comes from the rippling trunks resembling well-muscled arms or legs. These stems with smooth gray bark are especially showy in winter when all leaves are gone. Bright orange fall color is attractive too.

American hornbeam is a small tree that usually grows as an understory tree in the eastern half of the country. The wood is very hard and rarely splits, but it dulls woodworking tools and is not used very much commercially. Historically, it was used to make tool handles, mallets, croquet balls, bowls and longbows.

Trees are often multi-trunked with a spreading growth habit. Branches resist wind and winter damage very well. Roots hold firm in the soil too. I think hornbeams make a great substitute for Japanese maple, particularly on wet sites where Japanese maple often struggles.

Around here ironwood is usually found in wet places with shade or only partial sun. Often you’ll find it growing around the periphery of your property or on the fringe of swampy spots. These are places I like to accentuate its use.

Ironwood doesn’t transplant easily once plants are well established, so field growing and digging them could be problematic. That’s likely one of the biggest reasons they aren’t used more in the landscape industry.

Trees are also slow-growing. Individual specimens could remain healthy in a landscape for well over 50 years. That’s good for homeowners but bad for nurseries and many don’t raise them.

I’d like to see that change for three reasons. First, American hornbeam is a native species. Second, we could incorporate more variety into our landscapes. Finally, they resist damage by wind and winter storms.

Trees usually don’t flower until they are about 15 years old. Hornbeams have separate male and female flowers but both reside on the same plant. Flowers aren’t especially showy but the seed clusters are. They usually persist until early winter.

These clusters contain structures called nutlets. They are edible and have flavor similar to hazelnuts, but they’re small and cleaning enough for a meal would probably burn more energy than you’d derive from them. Squirrels and other wildlife like them though.

While squirrels and birds eat the seeds, few animals feed off the foliage. Deer generally leave hornbeam alone unless nothing else is available. Rabbits don’t fool with them much either. Beavers sometimes eat the bark, but beavers aren’t a major landscape menace, at least in most places.

Relatively few insects and diseases are a problem for this species. Drought tolerance is not particularly good, especially in sunny locations. However, productivity under wet conditions balances that out. Trees also require little pruning. Also, several species of butterflies are attracted to them. Plusses definitely outweigh minuses.

Ted Manzer teaches agriculture at Northeastern High School.